📉 SMC 기법은 정말 효과가 없을까요?

As a smc trader myself in the past, and switched to Orderflow. Yup, smc/ict has some flaws.

Pros:
- it gives u the comprehensive process from bias, to POIs, to how to confirm entry.
Cons:
- each step of the process all has flaw.
- method relies on too many elements, that makes it complex than it should. Backtesting is invalid with that and hard to sustain the method over long term.
- they advertise "sniper entry", high RR trades. It's possible of course. Like everything is probability. But it is not sustainable and give traders an illusion of ego. There is no sniper entry and it doesnt matter how sniper entry is. HFT algo entries are different.

There is a lot of noise in day trading. And most of the time just confuses the actual practice. Check out Step One by George Herrera on Amazon. It’s a practice guide for day trading execution.

Everything works, it's all about the degree of refinement and market experience.

Do your own research. Read books. Do back testing. Paper trade a strategy. Nobody here is gonna do that for you and even if they did you still might not be profitable because of your trading psychology. If you aren't willing to do the work to find a strategy it's pointless to try and help you because you won't put in the work to improve the other factors of trading.